About this trial
This study aims to determine whether electrical stimulation of the ear, when combined with physical and speech therapy, can improve symptoms in subjects diagnosed with Parkinson´s disease, by comparing two different application sites.
Each subject will undergo an initial in-person screening and provide consent before participating in the study.
The main questions to answer are:
* Does transcutaneous electrical nerve stimulation (tVNS) in the ear paired with physical and speech therapy improve speech and voice-related problems, airway protection, salivation, and swallowing? * Does tVNS paired with physical and speech therapy improve tremor, walking speed, and balance in people with PD? * Does tVNS paired with physical and speech therapy improve heart rate and heart rate variability in people with PD? * Do its effects persist at 8 weeks?
Participants will:
Attend 12 rehabilitation sessions over 4 weeks (three per week). During each session, participants received either active or sham tVNS, accompanied by speech therapy (once per week), physical therapy (once per week), or conducted alone (once per week).
Undergo speech, voice, swallowing, respiratory, gait, balance, tremor, heart rate variability, and cognitive testing, as well as questionnaires regarding the quality of life, before and after treatment.
Return for a follow-up visit eight weeks after therapy to check how long the effects last.
Eligibility criteria
This trial does not accept healthy volunteersQualifiers
Being a member of the Association or be interested in joining;
Idiopathic PD diagnosis, stages 2-3 according to the Hoehn & Yahr scale; confirmed by neurologist
Ability to walk independently for at least 1 minute ant turn 180° without assistance;
Exhibiting symptoms of hypokinetic dysarthria;
Disqualifiers
Any contraindication for taVNS (e.g., ear lesions, pacemakers, defibrillators, or other electronic devices)
Previous vagotomy or previous application of electrical stimulation to the ear or brain, or treatment with high-intensity focused ultrasound (HIFU)
Voice or speech disorders caused by other medical conditions
MoCA score below 21
Trial design
Parallel
Treatments tested in this trial
Transcutaneous Electrical Nerve Stimulation (TENS) of Vagus Nerve
DeviceThe tVNS will be performed at 200 microseconds, with frequencies ranging from 20 to 200 Hz (30 seconds/30 seconds) for 30 minutes, in the area innervated by the auricular branch of the vagus nerve (cymba concha and concha). The individually titrated intensity will be set above the sensory threshold (intense tingling sensation) but below the level of discomfort.
Conventional Physical therapy
Other interventionPhysical therapy delivered to both groups consists of exercises aimed at posture alignment and body coordination, static and dynamic balance improvement, and gait quality. It will be delivered once a week, during a session of electrical stimulation.
Conventional Speech Therapy
Other interventionIt will focus on the orofacial muscles, the acquisition of a diaphragmatic-abdominal breathing pattern that integrates breathing with vocal production, voice training with exercises that enhance vocal quality and prosody, articulation exercises to improve speech clarity, and swallowing training. It will be administered once a week, during one of the three electrical stimulation sessions.
Sham Transcutaneous Electrical Stimulation of Vagus Nerve
DeviceThe sham- tVNS will be performed at 200 microseconds, with frequencies ranging from 20 to 200 Hz (30 seconds/30 seconds) for 30 minutes, with electrodes placed on the earlobe, which lacks vagus nerve innervation. The individually titrated intensity will be set above the sensory threshold (intense tingling sensation) but below the level of discomfort.
Treatment groups
Trial outcomes
Primary outcomes
Voice intensity
The PRAAT software will be used to test the voice twice, when sustaining till 10 seconds the vowel "a" and when reading a text at their usual volume. The intensity (voice volume, measured in decibels) will be recorded.
Voice- Jitter
It is derived from the sustaining till 10 seconds the vowel "a". Then, PRAAT software will be used to test the voice, discarding the beginning and the end. The Jitter is defined as the variation in frequency from cycle to cycle, a measure of vocal instability, expressed as a percentage. The higher the percentage, the more irregularities the voice will have.
Voice- Shimmer
It is derived from the sustaining till 10 seconds the vowel "a". Then, PRAAT software will be used to test the voice, discarding the beginning and the end. The Shimmer refers to the variation in the amplitude of the sound wave. It is a measure of vocal instability, expressed as a percentage. The higher the percentage, the more irregularities the voice will have.
Secondary outcomes
Voice fundamental frequency (F0)
The PRAAT software will be used to test the voice twice, when sustaining till 10 seconds the vowel "a" and when reading a text at their usual volume. The fundamental frequency (F0) is the oscillation originating from the vocal folds. It will be recorded in Hz.
Harmonic to Noise Ratio (HNR)
The PRAAT software will be used to test the voice twice, when sustaining till 10 seconds the vowel "a" and when reading a text at their usual volume. The Harmonic to Noise Ratio (HNR), a measure of the ratio between the periodic and non-periodic components that make up a segment of spoken voice, will be recorded. This ratio reflects the efficiency of sound production; that is, the greater the amount of airflow converted from the lungs into vocal cord vibration energy, the higher the HNR will be. A low HNR indicates a weak voice and dysphonia.
Maximum phonation time (MPT)
The participant will be asked to sustain the vowel /a/ for as long as possible after a deep inhalation. It will be repeated three times, and the best value will be recorded. The maximum phonation time (MPT) will be measured in seconds. The same procedure will be taken for the /s/.
Maximum expiratory time during sustained /s/
The participant will be asked to sustain the /s/ sound for as long as possible after a deep inhalation. It will be repeated three times, and the best value in seconds will be recorded.
Other outcomes
Effectiveness of blinding
Participants will be asked what stimulation they think they have just received, active or placebo (or what is their best guess) and why. Comparison of participants´perceptions with the actual assignment, James Bang Index.
Adverse effects
A questionnaire will be used to test the presence, severity, persistence and causality of ear pain, headache, tingling, itching, redness, irritation, pressure, dizziness, nausea, vertigo, fatigue, vertigo, palpitations, tinnitus, unpleasant feeling, and/or other effects.
Tolerance to auricular TENS
The level of tolerance of the entire stimulation (by electrical stimulation, by electrodes, or by both) will be measured on a VAS scale from 0 (no discomfort at all) to 10 (the discomfort would have prevented me from finishing the session).
Amplitude of electrical stimulation
Amplitude used in the auricular electrical stimulation in mA, as well as the sensory and discomfort threshold.
Sponsors and contacts
Click on the lead sponsor to view all of their trials.
Universidade da Coruña
Lead sponsor
Parkinson´s Association Galicia-Coruña
Collaborator