Modified Mini-PCNL Versus Standard PCNL for Complex Kidney Stones

Kidney stones that are large or complex are often treated with percutaneous nephrolithotomy, also called PCNL. Standard PCNL uses a larger access tract and is effective for removing complex kidney stones, but it may be associated with more bleeding, pain, and recovery burden. Modified mini-PCNL uses a smaller access tract and may reduce surgical trauma while maintaining a similar stone clearance rate.

This multicenter randomized trial will compare modified mini-PCNL using a 20 Fr access sheath with standard PCNL using a 24 Fr access sheath in adults with complex renal stones. About 1,380 participants from 8 urology centers will be randomly assigned to receive one of the two procedures. The main purpose of the study is to determine whether modified mini-PCNL is not worse than standard PCNL in achieving stone-free status shortly after surgery. Stone-free status will be assessed by low-dose noncontrast CT within 72 hours after surgery. The study will also compare stone-free status at 3 months, complications, operation time, length of hospital stay, need for additional procedures, and quality of life.